AI in Marketing: Friend or Foe? A Dublin Bar Tale

A marketer walks into a Dublin bar. No, this isn’t the start of a joke—it’s Andrew Tindall’s reflection on Google Marketing Live 2025, where AI took center stage. The event showcased tools like Smart Bidding Exploration and Generative AI, promising to revolutionize marketing by automating campaigns in seconds. But with machines handling the heavy lifting, what’s left for humans?

The AI Stack: A Marketer’s New Frontier

Google’s AI stack is designed to automate bidding, asset creation, and even campaign structuring. Marketers using AI reportedly see 60% more revenue growth, according to BCG. But while these tools are impressive, they raise questions about the human role in marketing.

Pint One: The Human Dilemma

AI can spot intent signals before consumers even know what they want, turning marketing into a Minority Report-esque experience. But as Orlando Wood pointed out, this is "salesmanship on steroids." The challenge? Ensuring AI enhances creativity rather than replacing it.

Pint Two: The Automation Trap

AI excels at automating tasks, but strategy and brand soul can’t be outsourced. Without human oversight, campaigns risk becoming generic and uninspired. The key is to use AI as a tool, not a crutch.

Pint Three: The Jargon Problem

Terms like "agentic advertising" are flooding the industry, but their practical meaning remains unclear. While AI can handle media plans, creative direction still requires a human touch.

Pint Four: The Mirror Effect

AI exposes marketers who rely solely on CTR tweaks and rational campaigns. With tools like Google’s Veo 3 enabling small brands to produce high-quality creative, the bar is higher than ever. The differentiators? Creativity, strategy, and emotional intelligence.

Pint Five: The Real Challenge

If AI frees up time, how will marketers use it? The opportunity lies in smarter briefs, emotional platforms, and memorable creative. The shift is here—adopt AI, but double down on what humans do best.